Unbiased My Perfect Pet Cat Food Review

Gently cooked fresh cat food frozen at the peak of freshness and delivered to your doorstep—that’s what My Perfect Pet offers. But what sets this brand apart from other fresh cat food brands and pet food delivery services? Find out in this detailed review.

The Cats.com Standard—Rating My Perfect Pet on What Matters

My Perfect Pet provides gently cooked, fresh cat food that is frozen to lock in its freshness and conveniently delivered straight to your home. But what makes this company stand out from other fresh cat food options and delivery services? This comprehensive review will provide all the details.

We give My Perfect Pet a 50 out of 60 rating or an A- grade.

Why Trust Cats.com

To prepare for reviewing cat food products, we dedicate significant time to researching the company behind them. This involves understanding the brand’s background, production practices, ingredient sourcing, and assessing customer feedback about their experience with the products. We explore testimonials on the brand’s website, other retail platforms, and independent review sites when available.

Once we’ve gathered sufficient information about the brand, we personally purchase various products at full retail price for testing at home with our cats. The evaluation process is entirely independent, free from brand influence. During testing, we consider practical aspects like packaging quality and delivery times, while also relying on our cats’ reactions to gauge their enjoyment and satisfaction with the food.

About My Perfect Pet

Before reviewing cat food products, extensive research is conducted on the brand. This includes understanding its history, production practices, sourcing methods, and customer feedback regarding both the company and its offerings. Reviews from the brand’s website, retail platforms, and third-party review sources are analyzed for a comprehensive perspective.

Once sufficient insight into the brand is gained, various products are purchased at full price for testing at home with our own cats. The evaluation process is independent and free from brand influence. Observations include practical aspects like packaging and delivery speed, as well as the product’s quality. Our cats play a crucial role in assessing the food’s appeal and overall satisfaction.

Sourcing and Manufacturing

My Perfect Pet produces food using human-grade ingredients, prepared in FDA-approved facilities. Their process involves baking meats at FDA-recommended temperatures, mixing them with raw vegetables, and grinding them into a fine consistency. Once cooked and blended, supplements are added after the food has cooled to preserve their quality. The food is portioned into 4-ounce servings, individually packaged, and frozen to maintain freshness without the need for preservatives.

The company operates its own facility in Sulphur Springs, Texas, and sources most of its ingredients from the U.S., except for lamb from New Zealand or Australia and coconut oil from the Philippines. They emphasize sustainability by carefully selecting ingredients and using recyclable packaging materials.

Recall History

As far as we know, there has never been a recall involving My Perfect Pet. This is particularly noteworthy since the company was established following the most significant pet food recall in history.

What Kind of Cat Food Does My Perfect Pet Offer?

It sounds like you had a great experience testing My Perfect Pet with your cat, Oliver! It’s good to know that the packaging is compact, even though it needs freezer storage. The fact that the food mimics a natural diet for cats, with high protein and no fillers, is definitely appealing. It’s interesting that Oliver showed a preference for the chicken recipe—seems like he enjoyed exploring his inner hunter!

What Did Our Test Cats Think?

To test My Perfect Pet with my own cat, I ordered both recipes: Toby’s Turkey and Low Phosphorus Chicken. The food comes in packs of individually wrapped bars that must be kept frozen to stay fresh until feeding, which could be inconvenient for those with low freezer space. However, they are condensed pretty flat and not very bulky compared to some other frozen products.

Once thawed, they both have a moist and meaty texture. The high protein content with no fillers allows for a highly nutritious meal mimicking what cats would eat naturally. I could tell that my cat Oliver was happily getting a taste for his wild side while eating. He was curious to try both recipes, but preferred the chicken.

My Perfect Pet Cat Food—Top Recipes Reviewed

What Do Customers Think of My Perfect Pet Cat Food?

Reviews for My Perfect Pet products seem to be quite limited outside of a few detailed evaluations on independent pet websites. On the company’s own website, both cat food items have fewer than 10 reviews, and the testimonials shared there are primarily from dog owners.

The brand has a significant presence on social media, with a notable following on platforms like Facebook and Instagram. Despite this, the number of reviews on these platforms is quite low and often outdated. On the other hand, the reviews featured on their website are relatively recent, all appearing within the last three months. This could suggest that the company might be selectively displaying reviews, possibly favoring higher-rated ones.

Positive Reviews

Customers appear to be happy with the ingredient quality in My Perfect Pet cat food, frequently noting that their cats enjoy it. Many reviews highlight the brand’s unique qualities, such as offering a formula free of chicken and one with low phosphorus content.

“My cat Riley was diagnosed with early-stage kidney disease.  We wanted to get him on a good diet to help restore his kidneys to good functioning. Including raw low phosphorus food was a key focus. The My Perfect Pet Cat Low Phosphorus Chicken frozen bars fit the bill.  Riley likes this food, and it remains a primary part of his healthy diet.”—Jean T. reviewing My Perfect Pet Low Phosphorus Chicken Carnivore Blend on October 8, 2024

“Wow, finally a human grade food that doesn’t have chicken, peas and oats which my guy is extremely allergic too. Did I mention that he absolutely goes nuts for his food.”—Steven M. reviewing My Perfect Pet Toby’s Turkey Carnivore Blend on September 10, 2024

Negative Reviews

It appears that negative feedback on My Perfect Pet products is quite scarce, likely because there aren’t many reviews available online. The only recent criticism found seemed to come from a customer who may have misunderstood either the proper serving method for the frozen food or the appropriate portion size for their cat.

“What is my cat supposed to do? Eat the bar??”—Wendy J. reviewing My Perfect Pet Low Phosphorus Chicken Carnivore Blend on June 11, 2024

How Much Does My Perfect Pet Cat Food Cost?

My Perfect Pet offers fresh cat food in 3-pound boxes, each containing 60 individually wrapped 4-ounce frozen food bars. Customers can choose between a one-time purchase or a subscription when ordering from the brand’s website. While subscriptions include free shipping, there is no associated discount; otherwise, shipping costs approximately $25.

Each of the two available recipes is priced at $224 per box, which breaks down to about $0.93 per ounce. This pricing makes it slightly more expensive than some other leading fresh cat food brands, such as Smalls and Just Food for Cats, as well as certain raw frozen food options like Viva.

Feeding a 10-pound cat My Perfect Pet’s complete and balanced cat food costs an estimated $3.50 per day. Their other product is intended for supplemental feeding only but is priced the same per ounce.

Where Is My Perfect Pet Cat Food Sold?

The only way to buy My Perfect Pet cat food online is directly from their official website, where you can choose between a one-time purchase or a subscription plan. Subscription options vary, offering deliveries as frequently as every week or as infrequently as every 20 weeks.

If you prefer shopping in person and live in certain states, you might find this brand in local, independent pet stores. While these retailers are scattered across the U.S., California and Texas have the highest number of locations carrying the product.You can search for a location near you using the brand’s store locator.

Overall, Is My Perfect Pet Cat Food a Good Choice?

My Perfect Pet, while more expensive than many other fresh cat food brands, seems to offer value for the price. However, its single recipe may not be ideal for cats with dietary restrictions or sensitivities to turkey.

Purchasing a 3-pound box priced at over $200 can be a significant commitment, especially if you’re unsure whether your cat will enjoy it. Although they provide a refund policy, it requires the food to remain frozen and be returned via overnight shipping, which could end up costing more than the food itself.

One advantage this brand has is its availability in stores nationwide. This allows potential buyers to check the product in person and avoid shipping fees, especially in larger cities.

Similar Brands

If you’re searching for alternatives to My Perfect Pet cat food, take a look at our reviews of other popular brands.